NFL Week 15 Coaching Decisions: Game Manager QBs Aren’t Bad After All

Cam Newton stirred up controversy last week by labeling quarterbacks like Tua Tagovailoa, Dak Prescott, and Brock Purdy as game managers, a term he also extended to the legendary Tom Brady. While some were quick to criticize Newton, it’s essential to acknowledge that being called a game manager shouldn’t be viewed as a slight to quarterbacks.

As a former league MVP, Newton brings credibility to his insights, and he’s right in emphasizing that game management is a crucial aspect of quarterbacking. Protecting the football and efficiently executing plays are indispensable qualities for success in the NFL. Even quarterbacks with elite skills can struggle if they can’t be relied upon to make the right reads and safeguard the ball.

Tom Brady, often labeled the ultimate game manager, serves as a prime example. While not known for athleticism, Brady’s cerebral approach made him a game changer, securing victories for both the New England Patriots and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

The recent performance of Case Keenum reinforces the value of a game manager. Filling in for the injured C.J. Stroud, Keenum played a pivotal role in the Texans’ overtime victory against the Titans. Despite fitting the stereotypical profile of a game manager, Keenum’s contribution, like many Pro Bowlers and trusted backups, showcased the importance of effectively running the team’s scheme.

This discussion prompts us to reconsider the perception of game managers, highlighting that their role is vital and often underestimated. The ability to make life easier for the quarterback, as seen in Keenum’s case, is a commendable trait. As we reflect on Week 15 in the NFL, let’s appreciate the diverse skills and roles that quarterbacks, including game managers, bring to the game.